SEL Assessment » Tools » Needs and Outcome Assessments

To help schools determine the need for SEL in their schools, and the impacts existing practices are having on students, this section contains surveys to assess overall student risk-behavior rates and resiliency, and measures of student social and emotional competence. Although many SEL-related measures developed for the clinical assessment of children are available, relatively few of them are designed for use by school personnel. In addition, many existing measures are not in the public domain. Below, however, are some good beginning resources, including web sites with compendiums and descriptions of different measures and direct links to some measures that are in the public domain. Most measures are for assessment of elementary school students, grades 3-8.

California Healthy Kids Survey
The Healthy Kids Survey is a comprehensive and customizable youth self-report data collection system that provides essential and reliable health risk assessment and resilience information to schools, districts, and communities. Targeted at grades 5-12, the HKS enables schools and communities to collect and analyze valuable data regarding local youth health risks, assets, and behaviors. It is designed to be part of a comprehensive data-driven decision-making process to help guide the development of more effective health, prevention, and youth development programs. At the heart of the HKS is a research-based “Core” module that provides valid indicators of drug use, violence, crime, and physical and mental health. In addition to the Core, there are five supplementary modules to choose from that ask detailed questions on specific topics. Among these, the Resilience and Youth Development Module measures 11 external assets and 6 internal assets. The external assets include caring relationships, high expectations, and opportunities for meaningful participation in the school, home, community, and peer group. Internal assets consist of cooperation and communication, empathy, problem-solving, self-efficacy, self-awareness, and goals and aspirations. There is also a custom module for incorporating additional questions targeting topics of local interest.

All of the surveys are available in Spanish and English.

CSAP Measures
The Center for Substance Abuse Prevention (CSAP) has developed a compendium of evaluation measures to assess actual use of substances and risk and protective factors related to substance use. Most measures in the compendium are reasonable in length, free, in the public domain, and widely used. CSAP has provided reliability and validity information about each measure, including information about the target population.

Because the compendium was designed for programs that were specifically designed to prevent substance use (grantees of CSAP), most of the measures under the first two domains (ATOD and Individual/Peer) tap attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors related to substance use. However, measures included in the remaining three sections (Family, School, and Community) may be applicable to a wide range of programs since they assess individual and environmental risk and protective factors that cut across many problem domains. Some of the individual/peer domain items tap general SEL skills such as stress management, problem solving, social skills, goal setting, assertiveness, leadership, and antisocial behavior (see pages 70-114). Starting on page 18 of the compendium, you can find a table listing all indicators and instruments for the various domains.

The entire document is available here.

Child Trends Youth Developmental Outcomes Compendium
This compendium by Child Trends provides both extensive theoretical overviews and relevant items on the following four youth development outcome domains and subdomains:

  • Educational Achievement: academic achievement, academic motivation, and school bonding
  • Health and Safety: risky behavior, health, and mental health
  • Social and Emotional Development: social/community relationships and emotional/personal development
  • Self-Sufficiency: work and family

Each of the sub-domains is divided into specific outcomes. The Youth Outcome Grid section of the compendium provides information on which outcomes belong to each of the four broad domains.
Each outcome construct is reviewed in terms of the following aspects:

  • What is the construct and why is it important?
  • Measurement (measures or questions) of the construct
  • Experimental studies measuring the impact of programs designed to influence the outcome construct

Most of the items provided for the constructs were drawn from national surveys in the public domain. To facilitate comparison with the norms derived from nationally represented groups, benchmark information is provided when available. This compendium covers constructs ranging from personal skills and relationships to civic engagement, productive use of non-school time, and spirituality. Many practitioners and researchers in the field of youth development and prevention programs will find this compendium valuable for its extensive review of literature and programs in combination with actual measures.

Youth Outcomes Compendium

Character Education Partnership Compendium
The Character Education Partnership web site has an "Assessment Instrument Index" with a listing of survey instruments used to measure various SEL-related variables. For each instrument category, there is a grid specifying the grade level for which the measure is designed, who fills out the survey (e.g. students, teachers, administrators), and the measure's validity and reliability. Clicking on the measure name will take you to a description of the measure, and provide contact information for obtaining it.

More info is available here.

Communities that Care Youth Survey
The Communities That Care Youth Survey measures 19 risk and 10 protective factors as well as current levels of substance abuse, violence, and delinquency. The survey is designed for students in grades 6th through 12th. Its purpose is to help communities identify the risk and protective factors that pose the most significant challenges and opportunities in the community.

Developmental Studies Center Child Development Project Scales
The Developmental Studies Center has posted its Child Development Project assessment scales on its site. These scales, developed and validated for over 20 years, measure students’ social, emotional, ethical, and academic development, as well as student involvement in high-risk behaviors. The scales also measure aspects of school climate, including student perceptions of the school community, student-teacher relationships, and liking of school.

Fast Track Compendium
The Fast Track web site has a compendium of more than 100 measures that have been used to evaluate the Fast Track project. Fast Track is a comprehensive, multi-site intervention designed to prevent serious and chronic antisocial behavior in a sample of children identified as at high risk at school entry because of their conduct problems in kindergarten and home. The measures are grouped alphabetically, and the purpose of each measure is described. The site also includes PDFs of public domain measures and contact information for private domain measures. Below are some of the public domain measures, with a short description taken from the web site.

To download these and other available measures or to learn more about them, visit the Fast Track site.

  • Social Competence Scale—Teacher Version: A 25-item measure that assesses a child's prosocial behaviors, emotional self-regulation, and academic skills.
  • Values Questionnaire: The Values Questionnaire is a 35-item measure that explores parents' values about their children's peer relations.
  • Teacher Practices: The questionnaire consists of 27 items meant to assess teacher practices, values and classroom-level assessment: classroom activities focused on community service, conflict resolution, teacher goals and priorities for classroom instruction, and comparison of the social competence of the current class to previous classes.
  • Adolescent Stories: The Adolescent Stories measure is a social-cognitive interview. It assesses the adolescent's attitudes and enables expression of his/ her feelings and reactions when presented with an unfair situation.
  • Interview on Emotional Experiences: The Interview on Emotional Experience is a 22-item measure given to children. The measure focuses on four emotions-happiness, sadness, anger, and worry/nervousness. For each emotion, the child is asked several questions about the emotion and the interviewer then codes the child's responses.
  • The Social Problem Solving Scale: Assesses the way a child resolves problems encountered in typical social settings with other children. The scale contains eight drawings of social situations with children. An interviewer elicits information from the child that expresses how the child would interact with the children in each picture.

The Individual Protective Factors Index (IPFI)
Developed by EMT Associates, the Individual Protective Factors Index (IPFI) can be used as a tool for evaluating prevention programs. One of the few measures on adolescence resiliency and protective factors available in public domain, the items of the IPFI measure constructs related to adolescent resiliency, including social bonding, personal competence, and social competence. Sub-constructs for each of these three resiliency domains are as follows:

  • Social Bonding : School; Family; Pro-Social Norms
  • Personal Competence: Self-Concept; Self-Control; Self-Efficacy; Positive Outlook
  • Social Competence: Assertiveness; Confidence; Cooperation

In addition to resiliency and protective factors, the index also measures individual, family, peer, and neighborhood risk factors for substance use.

The survey is available here.

National Center for Injury Prevention and Control: Measuring Violence Compendium
This compendium contains more than 170 measures, and provides researchers and prevention specialists with a set of tools to assess violence-related beliefs, behaviors, and influences, as well as to evaluate programs to prevent youth violence. Most of the measures in this compendium are intended for use with youths between the ages of 11 and 24 years, to assess such factors as serious violent and delinquent behavior, conflict resolution strategies, social and emotional competencies, peer influences, parental monitoring and supervision, family relationships, exposure to violence, collective efficacy, and neighborhood characteristics. The compendium also contains a number of scales and assessments developed for use with children between the ages of 5 and 10 years, to measure factors such as aggressive fantasies, beliefs supportive of aggression, attributional biases, prosocial behavior, and aggressive behavior.

Teacher-Child Rating Scale
This scale consists of 32 items assessing positive and negative aspects of a child's socio-emotional school adjustment. By grouping these items into four empirically derived scales, the T-CRS assesses:

  • Task orientation
  • Behavior Control
  • Assertiveness
  • Peer social skills

The T-CRS measures teacher agreement using a five-point Likert scale. Summary record sheets and an Examiners Manual are also available. The cost for 25 rating forms is $20 at this site.

Youth Risk Behavior Survey
The "YRBS" 2007 surveys for middle and high school students are self-report questionnaires used to determine rates of various adolescent high-risk behaviors. Schools that use these items in needs and outcome assessment can compare and contrast their local data with national findings collected annually in all 50 states by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

» print this page

 

 
©2000-2008 CASEL. All rights reserved.
Working to establish social and emotional learning as an essential part of education from preschool through high school.